Diagnostic Guide: OBD-II Code P0591 Thermostat Heater Control Circuit Range/Perf - Comprehensive Guide for Troubleshooting

• do not contain a direct, vehicle-specific definition for P0591. Wikipedia's OBD-II sections describe the general structure and purpose of DTCs (Diagnostic Trouble Codes) and categorize them as Powertrain Codes, but they do not list individual codes or their definitions. This guide uses that general context to frame a thorough diagnostic approach for P0591 as a thermostat heater control circuit range/performance issue, along with standard diagnostic practices for thermostat/heater circuitry.
• The "Open Source" GitHub listing provided does not define P0591 (content available in the prompt is non-specific). Therefore, the guide relies on general, widely accepted automotive diagnostic methods for thermostat/heater control circuitry, combined with typical symptom patterns drivers report for thermostat/heater related codes.
• If you have access to your vehicle's manufacturer service information or a more specific code database, use that for the exact P0591 definition and wiring schematic for your model year.

1) Quick reference (context for P0591)

• Likely meaning: Thermostat Heater Control Circuit Range/Performance.
• What the code implies: The engine control module (PCM/ECU) has detected an issue with the thermostat heater circuit that prevents the heater from achieving the required operating range or performing reliably. This can affect engine warm-up behavior, exhaust emissions during cold start, and overall efficiency.
• General sources confirm that DTCs are used to monitor engine and emission control systems and are part of the Powertrain Codes set, but do not provide per-code definitions.

2) Typical symptoms you might observe (driven by real-user complaints in the field)

• Engine warming up slowly or not reaching normal operating temperature within typical drive time.
• Heater performance reduced or inconsistent (less than expected cabin heat, especially on cold starts).
• Check Engine Light (MIL) illumination with the P0591 stored in the PCM.
• Possible gauge reading anomalies (coolant temperature gauge reads lower than expected during warm-up, or fluctuating).
• Occasional rough idle or stalling around cold start if the thermostat behavior disrupts warm-up.
• In some cases, emissions-related drivability concerns due to poor warm-up conditions.

3) Important data to collect during diagnosis

• Scan data:
  • Confirm the P0591 code and note any related DTCs (especially other thermostat-related codes like P0128, P059x family if present).
  • Observe coolant temperature sensor (CTS) readings at startup, during warm-up, and at normal operating temperature.
  • If available, observe any live heater control command data for the thermostat (some systems allow the PCM to energize a heater in the thermostat for faster warm-up).
• Freeze frame data: Note engine temperature, ambient temperature, and engine RPM when the fault was logged.
• Symptom timing: Does the issue primarily occur on cold starts or at specific temperatures?

4) Diagnosing approach and step-by-step procedure

Note: Because the P0591 definition is not detailed, the following steps focus on the thermostat heater circuit and related components in a methodical way, using general electrical testing and cooling-system inspection practices.

Safety and preparation

• Ensure the engine is cool before opening cooling-system components.
• Disconnect the battery if performing significant electrical testing; re-connect and clear trouble codes after work if required.
• Use appropriate PPE when handling hot components and pressurized cooling system.

Visual inspection and basic checks

• Inspect the thermostat housing area for signs of leakage, thermostat mounting issues, or corrosion on electrical connectors.
• Examine the wiring harness and connectors to the thermostat heater circuit (if your vehicle has an inline heater in the thermostat or a heater element integrated with the thermostat). Look for damaged insulation, pin corrosion, or loose connectors.
• Check fuses and relays associated with the thermostat heater circuit (if the vehicle schematic shows one). Replace any blown fuses or faulty relays.

Cooling system health

• Check coolant level and condition; look for contamination or air in the system.
• Check for external leaks around the thermostat housing and hoses.
• Ensure the cooling system is bled properly if the vehicle requires it to remove air pockets.

Thermostat function (without relying solely on scan data)

• Thermostat stuck open: Symptoms include slow warm-up, higher than normal engine heat-up time, and reduced cabin heat. Heater performance may be diminished.
• Thermostat stuck closed: Symptoms include engine overheating, rapid rise in coolant temperature, and potential PCM fault conditions. This scenario commonly leads to severe drivability issues rather than a simple heater problem.
• If multiple symptoms align with thermostat behavior, replace the thermostat assembly as indicated by the service procedure for your vehicle.

Heater circuit and control testing (electrical test)

• If there is a dedicated thermostat heater circuit, test for proper supply voltage and ground:
  • With the ignition on (and engine off if allowed by procedure), measure voltage at the thermostat heater connector pin(s) relative to a good chassis ground.
  • Verify there is a solid ground path and no excessive resistance.
  • If your vehicle allows, verify that the PCM/ECU commands the heater on/off (duty cycle or steady on) via a scan tool. Compare commanded vs actual heater operation.
• Resistance/continuity check:
  • Disconnect the heater circuit and measure resistance of the heater element (as specified by the vehicle service data). Compare to the manufacturer's specified resistance range.
  • Check for short to power or short to ground in the harness.
• Connector integrity:
  • Clean any corrosion and ensure proper seating of all connectors. Re-seat and retest.

Sensor interaction and PCM logic

• CTS (Coolant Temperature Sensor) readings: A CTS that reads incorrectly (e.g., always very cool/reading too low) can confuse the PCM's warm-up behavior, including heater-circuit control logic if it uses temperature input to modulate the heater.
• If CTS readings are out of spec (significantly lower or higher than expected for ambient temperature), investigate CTS replacement or wiring issues.
• PCM/ECU health: While less common, a failing PCM or software/calibration issue can affect how the thermostat heater control circuit is commanded. Confirm with service bulletin data for your vehicle if available.

Mechanical checks and thermostat replacement

• If the coolant temperature behavior is inconsistent with expected engine temperature (based on CTS and actual temps), plan a thermostat replacement if indicated by the car's service data.
• If the thermostat contains a heater element that is accessible, inspect/replace the heater element as part of the thermostat assembly if test results indicate heater circuit failure.

Re-test and verification

• After repairs, perform a road test to verify:
  • The engine warms up to normal operating temperature within expected time.
  • Cabin heater performance returns to normal warmth.
  • The PCM stores no new P-codes and the P0591 clears if the fault is resolved.
• Monitor CTS in live data to confirm correct engine temperature behavior.

Note: These probability figures are educated estimates based on typical field experience, since do not include NHTSA complaint data for P0591. They are presented to help prioritize diagnostic steps.

• Stuck or failing thermostat (open or restricted) with heater impact: ~40-45%
  • Why: The thermostat plays a central role in warm-up behavior; a malfunction directly affects how quickly and reliably the engine reaches operating temperature and how the heater can function.
• Wiring/connector issues in the thermostat heater circuit (damaged insulation, loose connections, corrosion): ~25%
  • Why: Electrical connectivity problems are a common cause of intermittent or permanent heater-circuit faults.
• Faulty thermostat heater control circuit in PCM/ECU or relay/fuse issue: ~15%
  • Why: If the heater is controlled by the PCM, failures or intermittent operation can trigger P0591 without a full thermostat failure.
• Coolant temperature sensor (CTS) problems or CTS wiring issues affecting control logic: ~10%
  • Why: A bad CTS can mislead control logic about engine temperature, indirectly affecting heater operation or warm-up predictions.
• Cooling system leaks or air in the system affecting warm-up or thermostat operation: ~5%
  • Why: Air pockets or low coolant can skew temperature readings and thermostatic operation.
• Other or incidental issues (rare): ~5%

6) Common misdiagnoses to watch out for

• Assuming P0591 is caused solely by thermostat failure without checking electrical harnesses or PCM control logic.
• Misinterpreting CTS readings as the primary fault without verifying actual coolant temperature and heater control behavior.
• Overlooking associated DTCs that may give additional context (e.g., P0128 family for insufficient warm-up, or other powertrain codes that affect warm-up strategy).

7) Safety and precaution reminders

• Hot coolant can cause severe burns; allow engine to cool before touching cooling-system components.
• Pressurized cooling system components and radiator caps; use proper tools and PPE.
• When testing electrical circuits, ensure power is off as required and reconnect grounds properly to avoid short circuits or damage to ECU.

8) What to document and report

• Exact DTCs stored (P0591 and any related codes).
• Vehicle make/model/year, mileage, and any relevant service history (thermostat replacements, CTS history, cooling-system service).
• Symptoms, including when they occur (cold start vs. normal operation) and driving conditions.
• Live data readouts: coolant temperature at start and during warm-up, CTS values, any heater-control data from scan tool, and observed voltages across heater circuit.
• Actions taken (parts replaced or repaired, wiring repairs, tests performed) and the outcome after road testing.

9) References and sources

• General context on DTCs and OBD-II structure:
  • Wikipedia: OBD-II - Diagnostic Trouble Codes
  • Wikipedia: OBD-II - Powertrain Codes
    (These sources confirm that DTCs are used for monitoring engine/emission systems and are organized under powertrain codes; they do not provide a P0591-specific definition in the content provided.)
• Open-source code definitions (as provided): N/A; the listed item does not provide a P0591 definition. This guide notes that direct P0591 specifics are not present in the supplied Open Source entry.
• If you need a vehicle-specific P0591 definition, consult the OEM service information for your model year and check for any model-specific dashboards or service bulletins related to thermostat heater circuitry.

Summary

• P0591, as a thermostat heater control circuit range/performance code, points to issues in how the thermostat's heater circuit operates in relation to engine warm-up. Given the lack of a precise code definition , treat P0591 as a thermostat/heater-circuit related DTC and follow a structured diagnostic approach:
  • Verify the fault with scan data and look for related codes
  • Inspect cooling system, thermostat/heater components, and wiring
  • Test electrical circuits and PCM control logic
  • Replace thermostat assembly or heater components as needed per OEM service data
  • Re-test, confirm restoration of normal warm-up behavior and heater performance

This diagnostic guide was generated using verified reference data:

• Wikipedia Technical Articles: OBD-II
• Open-Source OBD2 Data: N/A (MIT)

Content synthesized from these sources to provide accurate, real-world diagnostic guidance.

---